Ballmerpeak devblog

Software development, related stuff and others

Reinventing the wheel?

March 05, 2016 — Richárd Thier

We have heard the phrase "reinventing the wheel" a lot of times, but are we sure we are using it properly?

The difference between "reinventing the wheel" and "not using the wheel of a car in a bicycle"

Lately I am working on 3D, VR/AR/MR among others and for making a short demo I have/had to find a way to show 3D models in *.obj file formats fast while knowing what I am doing. Those models are in a text format indeed so it is not that hard, however I have found out that many of the parsers for this thing are either too heavyweight or just not work in my case so I started to "reinvent the wheel". But here I did stop...

Is it "reinventing it" or just "creating a wheel that is known"?

If you study the book of "New Algorithms" and write a Dijkstra... ... some would say you are reinventing the wheel because you are not using some library that you might found - but this is not really reinventing - just "not using the wheel of one car in your car" or if you are lucky: "not using the wheel of a car in a bicycle". I wonder if others have written about these differences, but I thought it could worth a short post ;-)

Of course I like reusability, but the parallel is really wrong and in a way we can learn from it I think - in reality sometimes it would be great to see the other viewpoint that I show here now.

Tags: software-development, reinvent, wheel, philosophy

comments powered by Disqus